Principle of Subrogation in Insurance
Once the insurer pays, your right to recover from the person at fault passes to the insurer.
A truck rams Priya's parked car in Bengaluru. Her motor insurer pays ₹1.2 lakh for repairs under her own-damage cover. The truck driver was clearly at fault, so someone should recover that money from the truck owner. Not Priya: she has already been paid. Subrogation hands her right of recovery to the insurer.
Subrogation means the insurer, after paying a claim, steps into the shoes of the insured and takes over their rights against anyone responsible for the loss. It is a corollary of indemnity: without it, Priya could collect from her insurer and the truck owner and end up richer than before the accident.
You save ₹300
- Full 100-question mocks
- Principle-by-principle practice
- Section-wise sets
One payment, no subscription
The Rules of Subrogation
- Only after payment
- The right arises once the insurer has paid the claim. Policy conditions commonly let the insurer start recovery steps in the insured's name before payment; that is a contractual extension of the basic rule.
- Only up to the amount paid
- The insurer cannot recover more than it paid. If it recovers more, the excess belongs to the insured.
- Insurer stands in the insured's shoes
- It gets exactly the insured's rights, no better. If the insured had no claim against the third party, neither does the insurer.
- The insured must not prejudice it
- Signing a full release with the wrongdoer, or settling privately, can defeat the insurer's recovery and the insured may have to make good that loss.
- Indemnity contracts only
- It does not apply to life or personal accident policies. A family can claim the sum assured and still sue the driver who caused a death.
How the Right Arises
The textbook sources of subrogation, with Indian examples.
| Source | Example |
|---|---|
| Tort (a civil wrong) | A contractor's welding sets fire to the neighbouring godown; the godown's insurer pays and recovers from the contractor |
| Contract | A transporter loses insured goods in transit; the cargo insurer pays and pursues the transporter under the contract of carriage |
| Statute | Where a law gives a right to compensation for the damage, the insurer can exercise that right after paying |
| Salvage | After paying a theft claim on a two-wheeler, the insurer takes over the vehicle; if police recover it later, it belongs to the insurer |
Salvage and Total Loss
When an insurer pays a total loss, it is entitled to whatever remains: the wrecked car, the fire-damaged machinery, the stolen scooter if found. Often it is simpler to leave the salvage with the insured and deduct its value from the claim. IRDAI's master circular on general insurance describes salvage as the amount the damaged asset will fetch in the open market, deducted from the claim amount.
Either way the result is the same: the insured never ends up with both the claim and the asset.
Quick practice on insurance principles. No signup.
The Recovery Cap in Practice
Priya's repair cost ₹1.3 lakh; the insurer paid ₹1.2 lakh after a ₹10,000 deductible. The insurer recovers the full ₹1.3 lakh from the truck owner's insurer. It keeps ₹1.2 lakh, what it paid, and the ₹10,000 balance goes to Priya, who bore it herself. This follows Castellain v Preston (1883), where the court let the insurer recover from a seller who had been paid both by the insurer and by the buyer.
How IC-01 Tests This
Expect "when does subrogation arise" (after payment), "how much can the insurer recover" (up to what it paid), and "which policy does subrogation not apply to" (life, personal accident). The trap is confusing it with contribution: subrogation is insurer versus a third party; contribution is insurer versus insurer.
FAQs
What is the principle of subrogation with example?expand_more
After paying a claim, the insurer takes over the insured's right to recover from whoever caused the loss. If a neighbour's negligence starts a fire in your flat and your insurer pays, the insurer can then recover from the neighbour.
Does subrogation apply to life insurance?expand_more
No. Life and personal accident policies pay a fixed sum, not an indemnity, so the family keeps both the claim and any compensation from the person at fault.
Can an insurer recover more than it paid through subrogation?expand_more
No. Its recovery is capped at what it paid. Anything recovered above that belongs to the insured.
What is the difference between subrogation and salvage?expand_more
Salvage is one form of subrogation: on paying a total loss, the insurer takes the damaged or recovered property, or deducts its market value from the claim.
Next steps
Take a full IC-01 mock testFull-length IC-01 practice, timed and scored.